News from Moscow
Indian Woman Plunges 10 Floors to Her Death
Moscow, July 31, 2006
Moscow Times
Anatoly Medetsky and Carl Schreck
An Indian woman fell to her death from a 10th-floor
apartment in southern Moscow last week, and her relatives are
pressing the police to investigate whether the death is linked
to a $10,700 dowry dispute.
Indian police are refusing to investigate, saying
the case -- which is making headlines in India -- is out of their
jurisdiction. Moscow police believe the fall was an accident.
Ambika Sharma was found severely injured Tuesday
on the ground below her apartment in a diplomatic building on
Simferopolsky Bulvar, near the Nakhimovsky Prospekt metro station,
a duty officer at the local police precinct said Sunday.
Sharma, 25, was rushed to the hospital and died
at 8:20 p.m., about 90 minutes after the fall, according to a
police report seen by The Moscow Times.
The family had been observing a traditional Indian
fast, and Sharma had complained of dizziness, her husband, Sajjan
Sharma, a tea importer, told police, according to the report.
He said his wife had served him a meal and then
went to the kitchen when a friend came to visit, the report said.
Hearing a noise in the kitchen, he said, he went there, found
a window open and closed it. Moments later, he heard women's shrieks
outside, so he reopened the window and saw his wife on the ground.
He went to her, and she tried to talk to him, but in vain, the
report said.
Police concluded that the death was accidental after
questioning the husband, the friend, a building guard and several
neighbors, a source familiar with the investigation said. Neighbors
said the couple had not quarreled that day, said the source, who
spoke on condition of anonymity because he was not authorized
to release the information.
Police will close the case after they receive an
autopsy report, which could take two more weeks, the source said.
Ambika Sharma's family in Ranchi, the capital of
the Indian state of Jharkahand, learned of her death the same
night when a Moscow neighbor called them.
The next day, the family went to Ranchi police and
tried to file a complaint, claiming that the young woman had been
pushed to her death over an unpaid dowry of around 500,000 rupees
($10,700), R.K. Mallick, senior superintendent of the Ranchi police,
said by telephone.
Her family claimed Sajjan Sharma and his in-laws
took her to Moscow earlier this year with "foul intentions"
after the money was not paid, Mallick said.
He said his office had no jurisdiction to open an
investigation outside national borders. "But we might look
into a harassment case in Calcutta," he said.
Reached on his cell phone Friday, Sajjan Sharma
called the allegations by his wife's family "false and baseless."
He declined to comment further.
But he was quoted by Calcutta's Telegraph newspaper
as saying that his wife "must have slipped and fallen."
"It is a crystal clear case and has nothing
to do with murder," he said, the newspaper reported Thursday.
The Telegraph reported that the couple was married
three years ago in an arranged marriage. She had been living with
her husband and twin children in Moscow for the past two months,
the newspaper said.
Ambika Sharma's mother, Sharda Devi, claimed that
her daughter called her 10 days before her death to say she was
being abused by her husband's family and to seek advice, the Hindustan
Times reported Friday.
"She said that she was being beaten up badly
everyday, and her husband was using abusive language," she
was quoted as saying. "We used to think that they will mend
their ways, but all went in vain."
"They were putting pressure on Ambika to get
[the dowry money] from us as they wanted to purchase a flat in
Moscow," Ambika Sharma's brother, Basant Lal, told the newspaper.
Indian media reported that the husband's family
lived in his Moscow apartment.
Lal said the second man in the apartment was the
woman's father-in-law, Mohal Lal Sharma.
The source familiar with the investigation said
the second man was neither a relative nor a colleague of the husband's.
He did not elaborate.
An Indian Embassy spokesman said he was "aware
of this unfortunate incident." He said he could not give
any details or provide further comment.
The embassy counts around 15,000 Indian citizens
living in Moscow.
Thousands of dowry deaths are thought to occur every
year. Nearly 7,000 were reported in 2000, the Hindustan Times
said.
Though prohibited by law in 1961, the extraction
of a dowry from the bride's family still occurs, the paper said.
When the dowry amount is not considered sufficient
or is not forthcoming, the wife is often harassed and abused.
The abuse can escalate to the point where the husband or his family
burn the wife, often by pouring kerosene on her and lighting it,
usually resulting in death. The official records of these incidents
are low because they are often reported as accidents or suicides
by the family. In Delhi, a woman is burned to death almost every
12 hours.
Apart from the dowry deaths, 45,778 incidents of
torture by husbands or in-laws were reported in 2000.
News from India
Ranchi girl ends up as dowry victim in Moscow
Ranchi, July 28, 2006
ANI
Ambika Sharma went to Moscow to live with her husband
Saajan, never knowing that it would be her last journey on earth.
She became a dowry victim on July 25, and now her
parents, Deendayal Sharma and Sharada Devi, are running from pillar
to post trying to get a police case registered against Saajan.
Ranchi Police officials say that they cannot register a case as
the incident falls under the jurisdiction of the Moscow Police.
Ambika was allegedly thrown from the tenth floor
of a building in Moscow. Her body is now being flown in from Moscow
for final rites in India.
Ambika's brother Basant Sharma informed reporters
here that an anonymous caller had informed him on the night of
July 25 that his sister had been thrown down by her husband and
her father-in-law Mohal Lal Sharma.
"From day one, these people were very greedy.
They kept demanding more and more of dowry and we used to always
meet their demands. In November last, my daughter came here for
Chhaat Puja along with her husband and my son gave Rs. 25,000
to her husband Sajjan Sharma. They left for Moscow. On the night
of the 25th, my son received a call saying that our daughter is
no more," said Deen Dayal Sharma, Ambika's father.
Ambika's mother Sharda Devi claims that Saajan's
family used to torture Ambika a lot for dowry. Ambika's parents
made attempts to resolve their differences with Saajan's family,
but fate had something else store for her.
"My daughter told me 10 days ago that they
torture her so badly. What should she do? She said that she was
being beaten up badly everyday and her husband was using abusive
language. We used to think that they will mend their ways, but
all went in vain. We never knew this was going to happen. They
never bothered to even call us."
Social activist Rajiv Mishra has volunteered to
come to the Sharma family's aid.
"These people ran from pillar to post right
from the Kotwali to the SSP (Senior Superintendent of Police)
to the DGP (Director General of Police) but they have been bluntly
told that this case does not come under our area. We can register
the FIR (First Information Report). This was the saddest part.
They could have even initiated talks with the Russian Embassy
to help the family so that with the Government's intervention,
the matter is solved expeditiously," said Mishra.
Ranchi's Senior Superintendent of Police R. K. Mallik
said: "We can only register cases that occur in Indian territory.
If there is any foul play, then let the Moscow Police inform us
and accordingly we will investigate. Before that, as per the law,
we don't have any provisions to look into the matter."
Ambika married Kolkata-based Saajan Singh on April
17, 2003. Saajan Singh has tea business in Moscow. Last year,
she gave birth to twins in Ranchi. In April, Ambika's in-laws
took her back to Kolkata and then to Moscow.
According to the National Crime Records Bureau,
6,995 dowry deaths were reported in the year 2000 alone. Among
the 23 mega-cities, the share of Delhi was as high as 19.9 percent.
Though prohibited by law in 1961, the extraction
of dowry from the bride's family prior to marriage still occurs.
When the dowry amount is not considered sufficient or is not forthcoming,
the bride is often harassed, abused and made miserable. This abuse
can escalate to the point where the husband or his family burn
the bride, often by pouring kerosene on her and lighting it, usually
killing her. The official records of these incidents are low because
they are often reported as accidents or suicides by the family.
In Delhi, a woman is burned to death almost every twelve hours
.
Apart from the dowry deaths, 45,778 incidents of
torture by husbands or in-laws were reported. Though that number
dropped by 28 percent across the country, Madurai reported an
increase of 195.9 per cent and Hyderabad, 200 percent.
As for Ambika's shocked family members, the shattered
father with the hopes of securing justice will go to Kolkata to
appeal to the Russian Embassy to initiate investigation in unearthing
the facts about his daughter.
OPINIONS:
Below is the result of your feedback form. It was
submitted by
() on Wednesday, June 27, 2007 at 01:56:02
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Name_First112206: vishnu
LAST: sharma
City, Country: kolkata,india
EMAIL: vishnusharma1@yahoo.co.in,vishnusharma77@hotmail.com
Telephone :in file 033-26682164/6249
Name of this Article: opinion and appeals for late
ambika sharma
Add your (cut & paste) opinions/ comments/:
"dear sir/madam as per your article you have mentioned the
journey as the last one ,but i would say its also the first journey
for moscow in during her three years of marriage,he never took
her abroad anywhere also,even he didnot took her to visit india
except her mother's home at ranchi.first time in three years she
goes and have fallen from tenth floor by the kitchen window,moscow
kitchen are risky upto that extent that a girl slipped and fallen.
another point that why he took his father with him who never visited
a single country before this,the accused sajjan sharma have business
over 10 years in moscow,before this he never took any family member
there,according to indian culture a question arises that when
you both the couple have gone there to visit then why he took
his father with him.father even dont know any language except
indian hindi,he didnot know even english.
by examine sajjan sharma coment acoording to your report,i find
that his wife served him a meal,and went to kitchen ,he heard
a noise,he went there ,found a window opened he closed it ,then
he got shreiks outside and found her wife fallen.dear sir my questions
areas follows:
1)what type of noise that was which he heard?is it be a cat there
?my idea is that on the top floor no cat found..
2)he knew that his wife being there in kitchen why he didnot try
to get her that where she was?
3)from the tenth floor and after closing the window how she gets
a shreiks of a woman?
4)whose shreiks he heard his wife or any other woman?
5)what he did after getting fallen her wife she was alive nearly
90 minutes after fallen?
6)why he didnot bring the body timely to india ?
7)why he did not go through the lady parent in india that she
had fallen accidently and addmitted to hospital,?
8)why his friend ramesh verma have called the ambika parent at
approximately 12 pm india time?
9)why ambika parent have replied ramesh verma that "he have
killed my daughter"
9)in december and january2005-06 the couple have a huge quarrel
amomgst them ,ambika brother basant lal and her uncle have come
to kolkata and manage a relationship between them ,and they reaches
ranchi but on the next day again ambika call them and they again
come to kolkata to manage relationship.after that bad relationship
between them he took her to moscow and she found death ,i ask
is it an accident only?nothing has been not hiding by mr sajjan
sharma?
10)the girl several times claims to her family member of his cruelty
and torture from moscow.
11)the family member told that they always torture and do cruelty
with ambika in during her three years of marriage.
i appeal to you that you are a media which is capable to find
the truth,he has money and he is using it to get out for which
he get permission by indian court to visit moscow for three months
, he manage to get it which is harmful for the case ,i appeal
you that kindly try your level best that he cant visit to moscow
next time,upto the hearing of the case which is going on to india,
i further appeal that today is the money world,hire a good lawer
needs huge money and lots of stages are there which needs money
the ambika family is uncapable to bear such money needs,so i appeal
that kindly manage a donation fund for her that a lady can fights
for justice.accused is trying to manage everything by using money
power.please make a donation fund for her that she could fights.
Below is the result of your feedback form. It was
submitted by
() on Wednesday, June 27, 2007 at 01:56:02
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Name: vishnu
LAST: sharma
City, Country: kolkata,india
EMAIL: vishnusharma1@yahoo.co.in,vishnusharma77@hotmail.com
Telephone: 033-26682164/6249
Name of this Article: opinion and appeals
for late ambika sharma
Add your (cut & paste) opinions/ comments/:
"dear sir/madam as per your article you have mentioned the
journey as the last one ,but i would say its also the first journey
for moscow in during her three years of marriage,he never took
her abroad anywhere also,even he didnot took her to visit india
except her mother's home at ranchi.first time in three years she
goes and have fallen from tenth floor by the kitchen window,moscow
kitchen are risky upto that extent that a girl slipped and fallen.
another point that why he took his father with him who never visited
a single country before this,the accused sajjan sharma have business
over 10 years in moscow,before this he never took any family member
there,according to indian culture a question arises that when
you both the couple have gone there to visit then why he took
his father with him.father even dont know any language except
indian hindi,he didnot know even english.
by examine sajjan sharma coment acoording to your report,i find
that his wife served him a meal,and went to kitchen ,he heard
a noise,he went there ,found a window opened he closed it ,then
he got shreiks outside and found her wife fallen.dear sir my questions
areas follows:
1)what type of noise that was which he heard?is it be a cat there
?my idea is that on the top floor no cat found..
2)he knew that his wife being there in kitchen why he didnot try
to get her that where she was?
3)from the tenth floor and after closing the window how she gets
a shreiks of a woman?
4)whose shreiks he heard his wife or any other woman?
5)what he did after getting fallen her wife she was alive nearly
90 minutes after fallen?
6)why he didnot bring the body timely to india ?
7)why he did not go through the lady parent in india that she
had fallen accidently and addmitted to hospital,?
8)why his friend ramesh verma have called the ambika parent at
approximately 12 pm india time?
9)why ambika parent have replied ramesh verma that "he have
killed my daughter"
9)in december and january2005-06 the couple have a huge quarrel
amomgst them ,ambika brother basant lal and her uncle have come
to kolkata and manage a relationship between them ,and they reaches
ranchi but on the next day again ambika call them and they again
come to kolkata to manage relationship.after that bad relationship
between them he took her to moscow and she found death ,i ask
is it an accident only?nothing has been not hiding by mr sajjan
sharma?
10)the girl several times claims to her family member of his cruelty
and torture from moscow.
11)the family member told that they always torture and do cruelty
with ambika in during her three years of marriage.
i appeal to you that you are a media which is capable to find
the truth,he has money and he is using it to get out for which
he get permission by indian court to visit moscow for three months
, he manage to get it which is harmful for the case ,i appeal
you that kindly try your level best that he cant visit to moscow
next time,upto the hearing of the case which is going on to india,
i further appeal that today is the money world,hire a good lawer
needs huge money and lots of stages are there which needs money
the ambika family is uncapable to bear such money needs,so i appeal
that kindly manage a donation fund for her that a lady can fights
for justice.accused is trying to manage everything by using money
power.please make a donation fund for her that she could fights.
name: Submit
-------------------------
I was horrified to read about Ambika Sharma's untimely
death or should I say murder. For the sake of her parents, brother
and children I hope that her Ambika's husband and family are brought
to justice. I hope the Moscow police don't fall for the lies of
her death being an accident. We all know the truth. Greed and
the lack of value placed on female lives is abhorrent and I am
tired of people looking the other way and perpetuating this way
of thinking. Females have value beyond their dowry. In fact the
whole system of dowry should be banned. My heart breaks for Ambika's
family and children. How she must have suffered at the hands of
those who should have been there to love and protect her. Shame
on you Saajan Singh and your family. If you are not held accoutable
in this lifetime, I can assure you God will be your judge. I believe
in karma and you and your family will get what you deserve.
May Ambika's beautiful soul rest in peace and may God look over
her children....Navneet Zyon, Seattle, United
States, navneetzyon@mac.com
X 360
597-8072
Any
comments on this article or
you have any news: Click
here
Disclaimer
NRIinternet.com will put up as many of your comments
as possible but we cannot guarantee that all e-mails will be published.
We reserve the right to edit comments that are published.